Monday, October 22, 2012

To give complimentary tickets or to not give complimentary tickets?




This is a great question. This is also a dilemma of a question. As we relentlessly pursue new advertisers to experience the buying power of the performing arts audience, we from time to time get the inevitable question of whether we can get free tickets with the purchase of the playbill ad.  This is a question that we dread to hear because we are truly at the mercy of our performing arts clients. Philosophies on the subject of complimentary tickets vary. From our sales prospective, complimentary tickets can be a powerful sales tool.  Complimentary tickets satisfy the question of how an audience uses the playbill. They introduce the advertiser prospect to how the playbill is used after the event. The misconception being that they are discarded. Because everyone in the audience uses the playbill, it is this experience that allows the prospective advertiser to witness first hand how this unique marketing medium can work. A second positive outcome is that it can be a great sales tool for future ticket sales for the performing arts organization. We have had many instances where the prospective advertiser not only purchases the ad after going to an event, but actually purchase a subscription package. In more than one case the subscription package was not for that individual, but for the use of other employees in the organization.  The performing arts clients that we sell for have two different views of complimentary tickets. The first view is that complimentary tickets should rarely be issued. The thought being that it somehow diminishes the value to those in the audience that have purchased the tickets. My rebuttal to this argument is that perception is reality. Does it not give a sense of more value if there is less capacity available in the venue.  I have also heard the rebuttal to a request because THAT business owner already goes to the events. Here is my rebuttal to that.  In fact the owners of a particular business may in fact have a subscription already, but we work, in most cases, not with the owners, but marketing or administrative assistants that may not have the opportunity to go the events. These individuals may in fact not hold the subscription. There are some very valid reasons why a performing arts organization would not want to give complimentary tickets. One reason is that it will be a sold out event. There are those groups we work with that do an outstanding job of selling the events to 90% capacity, so in these instances it is a valid reason not to provide a comp ticket. It is also useful for our sales executives to have to explain that the house will be full. This gives us another reason for a potential advertiser to place an ad. 
"HOW TO SELL PLAYBILL ADVERTISING" "FREE PLAYBILLS" "FREE PROGRAM BOOKS"

Thursday, September 6, 2012

Advertising for Hedge Funds




This was some interesting news as of late. The Securities and Exchange Commission voted to propose lifting a decades old ban as early as October on advertising for hedge funds. This would give hedge funds wide latitude on ensuring they are selling shares only to investors who are wealthy enough to participate in such deals. 

How can a hedge fund advertise? Who is a hedge funds target customer? Where is the most effective market for hedge fund advertising? These are great questions. Targeting investors that are wealthy enough, can be a difficult task in and of itself. I recently came upon a demographic study for the audience of the Florida Orchestra. The study was conducted by Genesis Direct. What struck me about this study was that it included subscribers, those that held a season ticket, and those that simply purchased a single ticket for an event.  Here are just some of the fascinating findings from the study.

39% of the subscribers had a net worth of $1,000,000 +
25% of the single ticket purchasers had a net worth of $1,000,000 +

The study also described certain “Super Niches” of the audience. One of those Super Niches was “Diamonds-To-Go”. Here is how this niche was described:

Representing about 5.7% of Niches Households, the ‘Diamonds to Go” group are mostly homeowners with high income values, white-collar families with children. They have an average income of $123,000, with the average age of head around 48. bIt seems they enjoy the good life, with having multiple credit cards, and have an interest in home furnishings, stocks, computers, gourmet cooking, gardening and travel.  

This was just one demographic study for an orchestra audience. The Florida Orchestra performs in Tampa, St. Petersburg and Clearwater. There are hundreds of and these audiences across the country and they contain the highest net worth individuals in the communities in which they perform. (We should know as we produce a large number of these organizations playbills.)
"HOW TO SELL ADVERTISING" "PLAYBILL" "PLAYBILL" "PROGRAM BOOK" "FREE PLAYBILL"
I have the complete study in PDF format. For those that may have interest, feel free to email me korlowski@onstagepublications.com and I will be happy to share it.

I think what this SEC proposal will really open the flood gates, for marketing, as it did for attorneys in the 80’s. How to market a hedge fund. How to advertise a hedge fund. hedge fund advertising. hedge fund marketing.

Monday, August 20, 2012

Playbill Layout



So it is right about now that there should be a strong understanding of where your page allocations stand for your12-13 Season playbill. Allocation for ad sales as well as content pages. In the sales campaign, you have probably lost some advertisers from last Season, gained new advertisers (that should have more than compensated for your lost advertisers) and there should have been some advertisers from last Season that you were able to convert to a larger ad for the 12-13 Season. There are probably some advertisers from last Season that have not yet committed to the 12-13 Season. This is normal. These advertisers are the procrastinators. The way we like to forecast for this bank of advertisers is that if there is not an 85% probability for them to renew, count on them as not renewing. After you get a strong sense of where your pages stand, now there should be some considerable scrutiny on getting to that “perfect signature” ( see blog for perfect signature here:"Perfect Signature" blog   

How to accomplish this: Does it mean cutting pages, then which pages? Well if you have managed the number of budgeted pages for advertisers, there should not be any issues there.  On that note, here is an interesting scenario that just recently played out for us. We had a situation in which we had undersold by a half page color for a performing arts group. Here is how we were able to solve the problem very quickly. In this particular playbill we had not sold the inside back cover, which we typically sell as a premium to one advertiser. We immediately re-contacted some of the opportunities that we had cultivated early in the sales canvass. These were opportunities that had eventually declined participation for the 12-13 Season. We were able to sell a half page color (at a premium rate) for half of the inside back cover. We then approached our half page advertisers and offered them an upgrade for the other half of the inside back cover.  We were able to maximize our inventory, without sacrificing rate. We actually increased the rate. The reason the sales took place so quickly is that we presented it as a limited opportunity. It was a classic supply and demand equation. The next place to look for page allocation is content. There may be some tough decisions that will need to be made on this end as well, but these pages are generally easier to manage than ad sales, because you can’t negotiate the ad dimensions.   Hope this is helpful. By the way…I have had a tremendous amount of response from the "How To Make The Perfect Bloody Mary" blog. Go figure…
"HOW TO SELL ADVERTISING" "HOW TO PUBLISH A PLAYBILL" "FREE PLAYBILLS" "FREE PROGRAM BOOKS"

Tuesday, June 19, 2012

How to make the perfect bloody mary.


So I thought we would stray a bit from the ordinary program book talk and get into something really, really important. The best way to make the PERFECT BLOODY MARY. When ordering one of these drinks it is always a crap shoot.  How many times have we ordered this cocktail when out at a restaurant / bar and on the first sip it is either:
  1. Too watery and bland.
  2. Too hot and spicy
  3. Way lean on the alcohol.
  4. Too thick. (like a ketchup on ice.)
I have two recipes that really work well.  I should state, that for the record, the best Bloody Mary that I have encountered while out was at Fleming’s Steak House Restaurant. The only deterrent for me on this is the investment.  So here is the first Bloody Mary concoction.

This is a great recipe when you are making 1 or 2 glasses.
In a glass combine the following:
  1. Tomato juice (¾ glass)
  2. Vodka  11/2 – 2 Oz’s
  3. Lemon Juice 2 ½ Tbls.
  4. Huy Fong Sriracha Sauce 2 Tsp. (This sauce can be found at any grocery store. Here is a link as to what the bottle looks like.) Huy Fong Sauce Continer 
  5. Pepperoncini juice from the jar of pepperoncini peppers 2 Tsp.

    Morton’s Nature’s Seasons Seasoning Blend (a couple of shakes over the glass) –Here is a link to what the container looks like: Morton's Natures Seasoning container
Give this all a good stir, then garnish with a Pepperoncini pepper and celery stalk.

The next recipe is from Barefoot Contessa (Ina Garten). This will yield a pitcher of Bloody Mary's. This is an exceptional recipe if you are entertaining a number of guests (Or just yourself if you've had one of those days.).  For this recipe you will need a food processor. Here we go:

You know what rather than reinvent the wheel here, let’s get you a link to the process.


Please Drink, Layout / Design and Sell Program Book Ads Responsibly.

NOVEMBER UPDATE--------
Wow!!! Here is the killer Bloody Mary. I had the opportunity to enjoy this over the past weekend. It was introduced to me by a kid named "Chris Pursifull". (He is a graduate of Miamisburg High School class of 1982). Use Zing Zang Bloody Mary Mix. Here is what the bottle looks like: 
http://zingzangcom.easystorecreator.com Then add Absolut Peppar vodka. +AbsolutVodka Ng  THAT'S IT!!!! AWESOME!!!!!! Chris, from Miamisburg, Ohio, garnished it with a garlic stuffed olive. 
 "Chris Pursifull" "Miamisgurg Ohio"
  "miamisburg track" "Chris Pursifull was the fastest runner we ever had"

Monday, June 11, 2012

What should you charge for a playbill ad?


what is the cost of a playbill ad?
What does a playbill ad cost?
This is a question that we are asked quite frequently. What is the target rate for an ad? The way in which we tackle this problem is by working backwards. What I mean by working backwards is to first look at your costs of the playbill. Now once again I will refer you to an earlier blog:

When identifying the costs, it is absolutely critical to be able to identify all the costs. Here is the list:
  1. Commissions or Salary for salesperson.
  2. Time & wage allocated towards the layout / design of the program book.
  3. Time & wage allocated towards layout / design of customer ads.
  4. Time & wage allocated towards chasing the customers artwork / ad copy
  5. Pre-press and Print cost
  6. Fixed cost allocation
  7. Time & wage of collections of account receivables from the advertiser.
  8. Balancing the inventory of pages allocated for ads and content to make the most cost efficient pagination.
I can’t tell you how many times the only cost that is reviewed by an organization is the print cost. If print cost is the only cost used, the rate will be too low. More importantly the playbill will be a negative revenue stream. One needs to look at ALL THE COSTS. 

So basically you take your total costs PLUS what your margin needs to be and then divide by the number of pages of ad inventory. IMPORTANT NOTE: One needs to exclude pages that will be dedicated to sponsorships and trade.
 
So now, this will give you the rate for a full page black & white ad. 

Now once the rate is established for a full page ad. We can divide that rate by (2) and get a rate for a half page ad. Divide that half page ad rate by (2) and you get a base rate for a quarter page ad. I recommend adding an additional 5-10% on to the rate for a half page and quarter page. WHY? There should be a perceived discount for going with the larger ad. If you are selling color ads as well, you can use that same 5-10% premium for color. 

It is important to note that the rate that you establish will determine whether or not your playbill will be a negative revenue stream or positive revenue stream. You should be shooting for the latter : ) 

Just because you developed the rate card does not necessarily mean that it will work. A large part of the success of ad sales will be what the market will bear. We have been in markets where the ad will not sell because the rate is “too high”. Here is where adjustments must be made. You need to be VERY CAREFUL here. You can’t go so low that the margin is in jeopardy.

Hope this is helpful.

Wednesday, May 23, 2012

HOW LONG DOES IT TAKE TO PRODUCE A PLAYBILL?





This question was asked recently by one of our performing arts client. The question is relatively easy to answer. Since we are able to track time on each one of our program book projects, we have the data.  I looked at one of our mid – large distribution performing arts groups. Here is what it takes to produce a cost effective playbill for a complete Season in hours:

SALES:
Sales Campaign:
The project that I looked at was a typical season running from September to May of the following year. So when looking at time spent on this project from a sales window we typically begin the sales campaign in January. So from January through late July is the main sales campaign. (Keep in mind that we work with many different performing arts groups, so for this same period of time we are working well over 200 separate campaigns. But, if we were only working one performing arts group, the sales campaign would still begin in January.) 
The total number of man-hours that were dedicated to this particular sales campaign was 485.

PRODUCTION:
Layout & Design of playbill: 148 Hours
Proofing: 32 Hours
Customer ad design, layout & proofing: 51.75 Hours
(Note: with a customer supplied ad it will typically take 15 min. on average to manipulate to specs. If building an ad from scratch it will typically take on average 3 hours. In this particular example there were 41 ads sold and 25 of them were customer supplied and 16 were built by us.)

So total hours on production = 231.75
So total hours dedicated to the sales campaign = 485

GRAND TOTAL HOURS: 716.75 There it is! This time obviously does not include actual print time nor does it include sales time after the first book is published for the Season. What I mean by this is that we continually sell inventory throughout the season that may be available to use for ad space. Hope this is helpful…"HOW TO PUBLISH A PLAYBILL" "HOW TO SELL ADVERTISING" "FREE PLAYBILLS" "FREE PROGRAM BOOK"

Monday, May 14, 2012

THE BEST SALES AID



When selling advertising for a playbill, what is the best sales aid to use? We are asked quite frequently how we are able to sell so much advertising and what sales aids we use to sell advertising into the playbill. There are (2) sales aids that are key to a successful sales campaign. The first is what we refer to as the “fast facts” sheet. There is nothing like the excitement with announcement of the new Season. People anticipate this and the line-up should be a talking point every time with prospects. We typically “drill down” the Season line-up into a one page piece that showcases the highlights of the Season. (It is important that this piece is ONE PAGE.) I know that we see pages and pages of content in a Season brochure, but we have to remember that our goal is to sell advertising, not tickets. We have found that inundating a prospective advertiser with too much information can result in overload and failure.  

This one page piece should also contain the following:

  1. The Venues: Do not always assume that everyone knows where you perform. There are some organizations that we sell for that perform in (8) different venues in (4) different cities!!! This is VERY important as it will explain to a prospective advertiser where their marketing message will be seen. Just last week I was talking with a major hotel in Albany, NY. (for the Albany Symphony) The manager asked where the ASO performs. There were (3) venues. One was in Albany the other 2 were actually in Troy, NY. The Manager was not familiar with one of the venues in Troy. The venue was EMPAC.  (Experimental Media and Performing Arts Center). Of the three venues this was the newest, most prestigious and state of the art facility.
  2. Number of performances for the Season as well as the dates for the events. (NOT DISTRIBUTION) Including this information into the sales aid can be impressive. Including the dates is key information. Once again, don’t assume that everyone knows when your Season begins and ends.
  3. Imagery and COLOR.----- 98% of the time when one asks for rates for advertising from a performing arts group, it will look EXACTLY THE SAME. Typically include: distribution, rates by size, and of course the ad dimensions. (The dimensions will typically be a visual of the actual ad size with the dimensions.) It is always the same. We like to add flair. I’ll use the example of the Albany Symphony again. Yo-Yo Ma is the feature of the Season, so we have an image of Yo-Yo emblazoned on our fast facts page.  Since we email, we use a PDF of the one page “fast facts” sheet that always uses color.   
  4. Some general demographic information about the audience. Once again, don't go overboard with facts and figures. We have experimented with many different formats and have found that less is more. If one asks for more specifics, you can always accommodate with necessary stats.
  5. DON’T include rates on your “fast facts” sheet. As a sales rep, you ought not send over a list of rates and sizes and allow the prospect to decide what they should purchase. As a sales rep we want to control the recommendation. Here is an example. If you were speaking with the XYZ wealth management firm about placing an ad in the playbill, and we know that the ABC wealth management firm was already in the playbill with a half page ad. The recommendation for your prospective would have to be a full page. The logic: A quarter page ad, would be too small and not be effective.

In addition to the “fast facts” sheet, the other most important sales aid is the actual program book. Now we know that it is not practical or cost effective to mail out the playbill to every prospect. The answer is to digitize the playbill. We are able to email a digitized, page turn for all of our prospective advertisers. The importance of showing the current playbill is so the prospective advertiser is able to see the advertisers. 
Hope this is helpful....